Date of release: October 15, 2021 (Amazon Prime)
Story by: Shay Hatten, Sara Goodman
Teleplay by: Sara Goodman, Shay Hatten
Directed by: Craig William Macneill
”They're just rats.”
“That is a shocking response coming from you.”
“I'm a complicated person.”
The biggest question that popped into my head when starting this show: is it going to follow the slasher “And Then There Were None” formula that was also in the film series, or is it going to follow the novel more and be a drama instead of a bloody revenge thriller in which people's heads get cut off, and torsos get halved in size one by one? The novel's author, Lois Duncan, was never particularly happy with the format of the film adaptations, so maybe the television adaptation was more inclined to try its best to adapt the story? Then again, maybe this show just decided to throw it all into the wind and do something entirely different with the premise. Someone still got accidentally manslaughtered last summer, and now the only people who were supposed to know about it learn what it's like to fear the unknown. But other than that, is it going to be truly a slasher in the vein of the films, with the Fisherman wearing a hook and slicing people?
The first episode of the show couldn't hold back from delivering one big twist already, with the victim not being the person you thought it would be for half of the hour. It takes the potential slasher premise and adds a mistaken identity premise to it, with Allison deciding to full-on live as Lennon, and not telling anyone – for some reason (does the goat killer know?). Lennon's friends are also expectedly annoying – so much so that I would love it if they would run into a killer's hook immediately, as Allison's story turned out to be more intriguing after this episode, thanks to the twist ending.
Wasting almost the entire episode on what happened last summer felt like a waste, however. Sure, the writers took this opportunity to introduce the characters and establish the relationship between the twins, but since they are all late teenagers and annoying as heck, this episode was essentially grating on my nerves for 40 minutes, and slightly awakened my interest for the other ten. That usually doesn't bode well for the rest of the show, which makes me wonder if viewers of the show said the same, leading to the cancellation after the first season.
![]() |
The message has been received. |